Four Ways Your Mechanic Could Be Ripping You Off

Most mechanics are honest, but as is the case with any profession, there are some unscrupulous individuals who will bend the truth to fatten their wallets. Because of these bad actors, many consumers are skeptical about bringing their car to a repair shop.

And for a good reason. If your mechanic is dishonest, there are various ways they could be ripping you off, and you’d never even know it.

How Mechanics Can Rip You Off

If you’re visiting an auto repair shop, you probably don’t know cars from bumper to bumper (or maybe you don’t know cars at all). Dishonest repair shops might take advantage of your limited knowledge by ripping you off in one or more of the following ways.

Upselling Unnecessary Repairs

At most dealerships and independent shops, employees are encouraged to look for items they can upsell to customers. For example, while your vehicle is in for an oil change, the mechanic might notice a leaking radiator hose that the service advisor will try to sell you.

In general, upselling isn’t a problem, as long as the recommended repairs or services are legitimate. After all, if your mechanic spots a problem with your car, you’ll want to know about it.

But when a shop tries to upsell unnecessary work, that’s a different story. Shady repair facilities often try to pitch services⁠—such as flushes that the vehicle manufacturer doesn’t recommend⁠—or repairs that aren’t needed.

Overcharging for Repairs

Another way a repair facility can rip you off is by overcharging for repairs. Nearly every job has a standardized labor time (known as a “book time”), which shops can access through online databases. The book time is generally regarded within the industry as the amount of time a customer should be charged for a particular repair.

Some repair shops disregard or alter the book time, though, in an attempt to overcharge customers for labor. As a result, you could, for example, end up paying for five hours of labor when the job only takes two hours.

Dishonest shops can also charge you too much for parts. Of course, all repair facilities mark up their parts to some degree, but there’s a difference between making an honest profit and gouging customers.

Neglecting to Perform a Thorough Diagnosis

Unfortunately, some shops don’t have the desire (or the skills) to diagnose a vehicle properly. Instead, these so-called “parts changers” take their best guess at what’s wrong with your vehicle—and if they’re incorrect, they still stick you with the repair bill.

Because cars (especially modern ones) are difficult to diagnose, no mechanic will hit the nail on the head every time. But when a shop doesn’t bother to troubleshoot your vehicle properly, that’s a rip-off in its own right.

Billing for Work that Wasn’t Done

Perhaps the most significant rip-off is when a repair shop charges for work they didn’t even complete. For example, they might tell you they changed your spark plugs or air filter without actually replacing any parts—and you’ll have no clue the work wasn’t completed.

How to Know if a Mechanic is Ripping You Off

Do you have a sneaking suspicion that your mechanic is ripping you off? If so, you might want to consider doing the following:

• Ask your mechanic to demonstrate the problem: If your mechanic says there’s a problem with your car, ask them to point out (or send you a video of) the issue. A dishonest mechanic might have a hard time proving that there’s actually something wrong with your car.

• Read online reviews: Online reviews can be very informative. If a repair shop is dishonest, there might be other customers who found out and left negative reviews.

• Ask for your old parts back: Getting your old parts back after a repair is complete will provide some reassurance that your mechanic actually did the job.

• Shop around: If you think your mechanic is ripping you off, get a couple of quotes from other shops.

What to Do If a Body Shop Rips You Off

Here are some of the things you can do when a body shop rips you off:

Assess the Situation

Assessing the situation means taking a step back and determining whether the body shop ripped you off or if the shop naturally charges higher than usual for all its services.

Ask help from someone who’s more knowledgeable about these things or go to another repair shop for a second opinion.

Contact the Business

Contact the business and talk to them professionally about the situation. After all, you’re still dealing with humans who could’ve made an honest mistake during the entire process.

If they did, you can have your money refunded or ask the shop about other options you can take to make things right.

Contact Consumer Protection Agencies

The last thing you can do is reach out to consumer protection agencies, like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) or your state Attorney General’s Office. These agencies can help you remedy the situation, although the entire process will require paperwork on hand to support your case.

File a Dispute With Your Credit Card Company

If you paid with your credit card, you can contact the company to dispute the charge. Just be sure to have the receipts to support your position.

Conveniently Shop for Replacement Parts with CarParts+

With a CarParts+ membership, you can sigh in relief as you won’t have to worry about all the tedium that typically comes with searching for the right component for your vehicle.

CarParts+ offers excellent benefits, including VIP Customer Service. This includes white glove customer support with a dedicated members-only phone number and text-to-chat. You’ll be able to connect with team members who understand the unique challenges DIY enthusiasts face and can help you find the parts you need.

You’ll also get access to other exclusive perks such as 24/7 Roadside Assistance, Free Shipping, and Extended Returns. Sign up today to have that extra confidence on the road.